Saving 101 A Toast to Overdraft Fees — And How to Avoid Them Read the Article Open Share Drawer Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) Written by Mint.com Published Mar 15, 2011 5 min read Advertising Disclosure The views expressed on this blog are those of the bloggers, and not necessarily those of Intuit. Third-party blogger may have received compensation for their time and services. Click here to read full disclosure on third-party bloggers. This blog does not provide legal, financial, accounting or tax advice. The content on this blog is "as is" and carries no warranties. Intuit does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy, reliability, and completeness of the content on this blog. After 20 days, comments are closed on posts. Intuit may, but has no obligation to, monitor comments. Comments that include profanity or abusive language will not be posted. Click here to read full Terms of Service. (photo: [puamelia]) Last year, as you may recall, the Federal Reserve gave banks an ultimatum: if they wanted to continue charging customers up to $35 for each checking account overdraft, they’d have to get “opt-in” permission from the account holder. In other words, the bank gave you a choice: opt into the program, and the bank will continue to allow you to overdraw your checking account (and levy the charge) via ATMand debit transactions. Opt out, and those transactions will be declined; you may lose face at the checkout, but at least you’re not $35 poorer. (If you don’t remember making such a choice, well, more on that in a minute.) This was last August. At this point, we have essentially no idea how many people took the red pill and how many took the blue pill. The Federal Reserve doesn’t know. The FDIC doesn’t know. Last week a bank industry consultant in Illinois made headlines by claiming that over 75% of people have opted in; he wouldn’t show me his data and other analysts I spoke to were skeptical. Here’s what we do know, however: most people have access to cheaper alternatives than fee-based overdraft coverage. If you have a checking account, it’s time to flip your ATM card over, call the 800 number, and find out what kind of overdraft coverage you have. Because the fee-based kind that dominates the industry is about the most expensive way you can possibly borrow money. The cost of overdraft Say you opt into fee-based overdraft coverage. When you overdraw your account, the bank makes you a loan. The loan might be as small as a couple of bucks if (as the example always goes) you were debiting a cup of coffee. If you’re charged $35 and pay the bank back in a few days, that’s the equivalent of borrowing an astronomical rate of interest. When the FDIC looked into overdraft in 2008, they ran a model scenario in which a customer with an empty checking account withdraws $60 from the ATM, gets socked with a $27 fee (the industry average at the time), and pays it back in two weeks. That amounts to an annual interest rate of 1,173%, which makes payday lending look flat out charitable. You probably know all this already. Want options? Here are a few. How hardcore are you? Most people—about 75%, according to that FDIC study—never overdraw their account. If you’re in that category (be honest), you don’t need to care about this at all. (By the way, this FDIC data predates the Great Recession, so the percentage of squeaky-clean non-overdrafters has probably dropped somewhat.) We can divide the rest into two categories. The hardcore and the oopsies. (I made these terms up. Can you tell?) Hardcore overdrafters are the 14% of bank customers who overdraft five or more times a year and generate 93% of all overdraft fees. These folks, for the most part, are not accidentally charging one latte too many. They’re people with low credit scores (but not necessarily low income) who are using overdraft as an alternative to payday loans. “The serial overdrafters are also the least likely to have other alternatives,” says Greg McBride, a senior analyst for Bankrate. “In this era of tight credit, they probably don’t have credit cards, or they don’t have available credit on their credit cards.” If you’re in this situation, you don’t need me to tell you you have a problem. If the problem is overall indebtedness, consider Consumer Credit Counseling. Alternatively, if you have a revolving payday loan or overdraft that you can’t seem to get rid of, you might find a local bank or credit union that offers small dollar loans (SDLs). These are loans of up to $2,500 with capped interest rates that are specifically designed to replace payday lending and overdraft. Here’s a list of banks that participated in an FDIC small dollar loan pilot program; many still offer the service. Oopsies are the other 11%, who have an occasional overdraft (one to four per year). If you’re in this category, where overdraft is a genuine oversight and not a lifestyle, you’ve got plenty of choices. Options for Oopsies For a rundown of the choices available to occasional overdrafters, let’s turn to an unlikely source: Bank of America (BAC). To hear the American Bankers Association tell it, bank customers find overdraft protection convenient and the fees reasonable. “People want this service, and they’re willing to pay for it when they need it,” says ABA spokesperson Carol Kaplan. Tell that to B of A, which no longer offers fee-based overdraft because they said customers didn’t want it. (Citi doesn’t offer it either.) Instead, the bank offers several options: * Link your checking account to another checking account or savings account. Money will be automatically transferred into the empty checking account from the linked account. A $10 fee applies, but only once a day and only if you overdraw your account by more than $10. * Link your checking account to a line of credit. When your account hits zero, you start dipping into a credit line. There’s no charge other than the interest on the credit line, which is comparable to a credit card. You have to have a decent FICO score to qualify for this. * And, of course, you can simply decline overdraft protection completely and have your transactions denied. Insure yourself No one ever needs to pay an accidental overdraft fee. If you’re not good at keeping tabs on your balance, you can opt out the coverage and carry a credit card (or even a prepaid debit card, as long as it’s a low-fee one) as backup. You can ask your bank about lower-cost options. You can switch to a bank or credit union with kinder, gentler policies. (My credit union, for example, offers the automatic transfer option at no charge and the line of credit at reasonable rates.) So why are people still opting in? Beats me. “Look, the problem isn’t that overdraft protection exists,” says Bankrate’s McBride. “The problem is, people spend more money than they have in the account.” I’ll drink to that. Matthew Amster-Burton is a personal finance columnist at Mint.com. Find him on Twitter @Mint_Mamster. Previous Post Would You Rent Your Car Out While Not Driving It?… Next Post Frugal Beauty: 11 Household Items You Can Use As Beauty… Written by Mint.com More from Mint.com Browse Related Articles Mint App News Intuit Credit Karma welcomes all Minters! Retirement 101 5 Things the SECURE 2.0 Act changes about retirement Home Buying 101 What Are Homeowners Association (HOA) Fees and What Do … Financial Planning What Are Tax Deductions and Credits? 20 Ways To Save on… Financial Planning What Is Income Tax and How Is It Calculated? Investing 101 The 15 Best Investments for 2023 Investing 101 How To Buy Stocks: A Beginner’s Guide Investing 101 What Is Real Estate Wholesaling? Life What Is A Brushing Scam? Financial Planning WTFinance: Annuities vs Life Insurance